Three members of an Ohio family were sentenced Friday for their roles in the 2016 massacre of eight members of another family.
Angela Wagner, her mother Rita Newcomb, her husband George “Billy” Wagner III, and her two sons — Edward “Jake” Wagner and George Wagner IV — were accused in 2018 of planned and carrying out the murders of Jake Wagner’s former girlfriend, Hanna May Rhoden, and seven members of her family and extended family.
Angela Wagner, Newcomb, and Jake Wagner pleaded guilty to their roles years earlier, but sentencing was not handed down until Friday, the Dayton Daily News reported. And Judge Jonathan Hein shocked the courtroom when he tore up the plea agreement for Jake Wagner and give him the possibility of parole.
Hein had already sentenced Newcomb to five years probation for obstructing the investigation and Angela Wagner to 30 years in prison when her son came before him.
“How do I resolve the good deal your mom got, especially since she could have stopped the whole thing dead in its tracks?” said Hein.
His mother pleaded guilty to conspiracy, aggravated burglary, tampering with evidence, forgery, unauthorized use of property, and unlawful possession of dangerous ordnance. In exchange, prosecutors dropped eight charges of aggravated murder and recommended 30 years in prison with no early release.
Hein said he couldn’t balance Angela Wagner’s sentence with the proposed sentence for her son — eight consecutive life sentences with no parole, the same sentence his brother George Wagner IV received after he was convicted at trial in 2022 — despite both cooperating with investigators. Jake Wagner even testified against his brother.
“How do I resolve the good deal that your mom got?” Hein said, according to Law&Crime. “Thirty years is a really long time; that’s a really good deal for the level of the conduct. Especially since she could have stopped the whole thing dead in its tracks before it ever happened. And I don’t let her off the hook because she didn’t go to the scene. I put her equally responsible because the eyes of the law put her equally responsible.”
Jake Wagner pleaded guilty to two gun charges and eight murder charges. Hein sentenced him to six years each on the gun charges and life on the murder charges, to be served concurrently, with the possibility of parole after 32 years.
“Because you cooperated. Because you did something to acknowledge the responsibility for the crime,” Hein said. “That’s not a deal, that’s as close as I can come to solving the problem that was handed to me by these ancient plea agreements.”
Prosecutors alleged that the slayings were motivated by a custody dispute between Jake Wagner and Hanna Rhoden, as CrimeOnline reported. The Wagners were allegedly trying to force Rhoden to sign an unfavorable custody agreement. In a Facebook post that was produced as evidence, Rhoden wrote, “(I’ll) never sign papers ever. They will have to kill me first.”
The Wagners allegedly planned the killings for months and then moved to Alaska afterward. They returned to Ohio a few months before their arrests.
The eight victims were all shot execution-style at three campers and a trailer on a property in Piketon. The victims were identified as Christopher Rhoden Sr, 40, and Dana Rhoden, 37; their three children, Hanna Rhoden, 19, Christopher Rhoden Jr, 16, and Frankie Rhoden, 20; Frankie’s fiancee, Hannah Gilley, 20; Christopher Sr’s brother, Kenneth Rhoden, 44; and a cousin, Gary Rhoden, 38. Two children — Hanna’s children — were not harmed.
The last defendant, Billy Wagner, 53, has pleaded not guilty. His trial has been repeatedly delayed because of appeals.
For the latest true crime and justice news, subscribe to the ‘Crime Stories with Nancy Grace’ podcast.
[Featured image: Rhoden family/Handout]
